Winter Garden Dessert Guide

August 19, 2021
| 5:24 PM

Let’s talk desserts, especially desserts in Winter Garden. Just west of downtown Orlando, you’ll find amazing coffee shops, cupcakeries, ice cream parlors, and more!

We know you have a sweet tooth, so we’ve gathered the perfect list of dessert spots to satisfy all of your sugary sweet cravings! Follow along for our Winter Garden Dessert Guide!

1. Sweet Dees Cupcakery

Sweet Dees Cupcakery is here to bake the world a better place with its variety of cupcakes, cookies, and other delicious desserts. Owner Diandra, or Dee, has always had a passion for baking and grew up in Central Florida, so she knew she wanted to share her passion with the city.

Enjoy amazing flavors like cake batter with a vanilla pudding filling, plant street perfection almond cupcake, or the key lime cupcake with key lime mousse filling. Feeling creative? You can even design your own cupcake at the one-of-a-kind cupcake bar!

Hours & Location

(Custom Cupcake Bar closes at 6:00pm daily)

📍21 S. Main Street Winter Garden, FL 34789

Vist website

📷 Scoops Old-Fashioned Ice Cream

2. Scoops Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Store

Scoops, there it is! Scoops is an Old-Fashioned Ice Cream store that is serving up incredible flavors from their Winter Garden location. Located in the historic Edgewater Hotel, this ice cream shop gives you that authentic, soda shop feel.

Try their peanut butter pretzel explosion sundae with vanilla ice cream and peanut butter sauce, or their road runner raspberry. They can do soft serves, hurricanes, floats, sundaes, malts, and more!

Hours & Location

📍99 W. Plant St. Winter Garden, FL 34789

Visit website

3. Axum Coffee

Not just coffee at Axum Coffee, they also have amazing muffins, cookies, and of course coffee drinks that taste like dessert! Try their new summer drink menu items like the Malibu with rum extract and coconut, the honey mango lemonade, or the sweet cream cold foam.

Axum Coffee is on a mission to make a difference by cultivating community and relationships over exceptional cups of coffee. All of their coffee is ethically sourced, locally roasted, and handcrafted to give you the perfect cup every time!

Hours & Location

📍146 W. Plant St. Winter Garden, FL 34787

Visit website

📷 Rita’s Winter Garden

4. Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Winter Garden

At Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard, they believe that ice plus custard equals happiness and we would have to agree! Whether you’re into their creamy frozen custard, smooth gelati, or fresh Italian ice, there’s something for everyone on your list!

Custard flavors include banana, raspberry, butter pecan, cheesecake, pumpkin, mint, vanilla, and more! You can combine flavors in a Blendini, which is a mix of custard and Italian ice! Rita’s has been open for over 30 years and in 30 states so you know it’s good!

Hours & Location

📍119 S. Boyd St. Tremaine Boyd Winter Garden, FL 34787

Visit website

📷 Way Chocolate and Coffee

5. Way Chocolate and Coffee

Name a better duo than chocolate and coffee… we’ll wait. At Way Chocolate and Coffee you don’t have to decide between the two! This coffee shop in Winter Garden is serving you delectable crepes, dipped chocolates, pastries, and their signature spoon eggs.

Dive into their giant eggs filled with chocolate mousse, and choose between their variety of flavors like Oreo, brownie and Nutella, red velvet, key lime, and more. Don’t forget to grab an espresso with chocolate and a chocolate-dipped Twizzler on your way out!

Hours & Location

📍50 W Plant St, Winter Garden, FL 34787

Visit website

📷 Pop Love Winter Garden

6. Pop Love Gelato

When you need a cool and refreshing treat on a hot summer day, there’s nothing quite like a popsicle from Pop Love Gelato. Pop Love is the perfect combination of tropical fruits, traditional flavors, and Italian gelato all in a hand-crafted popsicle.

The good news is their fruit-based popsicles are low in sugar and only 86 calories, so it’s the perfect guilt-free treat when shopping around Winter Garden! Be sure to check out their amazing flavors like passion fruit, pineapple mint, or milk-based dulce de leche.

Hours & Location

📍3251 Daniels Road Winter Garden, FL 34787

Visit website

📷 Paletria Original

7. Paletria Popsicles

More popsicles and ice cream please! Paletria Original Popsicles are handcrafted popsicles made with 100% real fruit and some are even flavor stuffed. Yes, you read that correctly, we’re talking stuffed popsicles here!

You can enjoy their traditional fruit popsicles like mango, lime, or watermelon, or their creamy ones like cookies and cream or strawberry cheesecake, but you’ll definitely want to check out banana stuffed with Nutella, mint stuffed with chocolate, and more!

Hours & Location

📍426 W. Plant Street Winter Garden, FL 34787

Visit website

📷 West Orange Creamery

8. West Orange Creamery and Soda Fountain

Not too far from downtown Winter Garden, you’ll find West Orange Creamery and Soda Fountain in Ocoee. This ice cream shop is like an old-fashioned soda shop with a modern flare. They’re bringing back traditional and owner-created milk shakes, sundaes, speciality sodas, malts, and egg creams!

Try one of their epic shakes like s’mores overload or black and white classic, or try a cherry root soda phosphate. There’s something for everyone at the Creamery!

Hours & Location

📍1575 Maguire Rd Ocoee, FL 34761

Visit website

9. Three Birds Cafe

Can breakfast be dessert? We sure think so! And here at Three Birds Cafe you can have all the dessert for breakfast that your heart desires! Brioche French toast? Check. Vanilla Violet Italian soda? Check. Cinnamon Toast Crunch latte? You got it!

If dessert isn’t your thing, you can also check out their delicious savory options too like avocado toast, buffalo chicken dip, or chicken pesto sandwich. Run, don’t walk, to this new and adorable spot in downtown Winter Garden!

Hours & Location

📍2 W Plant Street Winter Garden, FL 34787

Visit website

📷 Sir Benji’s Donuts

10. Sir Benji’s Donuts

Who said donuts need to full sized to pack a real punch? Sir Benji’s Donuts is located inside the Plant Street Market in Winter Garden and has some of the best mini donuts around! Watch them flip and fry right before your eyes and choose your favorite flavor!

Summer flavors include guava key lime glaze, toasted coconut pineapple rum, and s’mores brulee. Choose between a dozen or half dozen, and enjoy these delicious, hot and fresh mini donuts!

Hours & Location

📍426 West Plant Street Winter Garden, FL 34787

Visit website

📷 The Bulk Pantry

11. The Bulk Pantry

The Bulk Pantry is a locally-owned bakery that creates custom baked goods that can also be made vegan, low carb, diabetic-friendly, keto, and gluten free. Know anyone with a birthday or other celebration coming up? Order one of their custom cakes!

Not only do they have gorgeous and specialty cakes, the Bulk Pantry also has keto lemon squares, peanut butter banana stuffed donuts, and triple chocolate cheesecake bars! We love to support local and delicious small businesses like the Bulk Pantry!

Hours & Location

📍103 S Main St. Winter Garden, FL 34787

Visit website

📷 DG Doughnuts

12. DG Doughnuts

Junky monkey, key lime pie, birthday cake, peanut butter power up, oh my! If these doughnut flavors sound good to you then you’ll definitely want to check out DG Doughnuts located in Oakland. Open every day until they sell out!

DG Doughnuts is a small-batch, family-owned doughnut shop that takes pride in making delicious and unique doughnuts. They start with a large yeast doughnut, and add incredible flavors and toppings to create something you won’t find anywhere else!

Hours & Location

📍 16131 West Colonial Drive Oakland, Florida 34787

Visit website

📷 Abbott’s Hamlin

13. Abbott’s Frozen Custard

Abbott’s Frozen Custard is a frozen custard franchise that was founded and based in Rochester, New York, but we are so glad that they have a location in Winter Garden! Starting in 1902, Arthur Abott practiced and perfected his creamy frozen custard recipe that is still used today in all their stores!

Try their amazing peanut butter fluffer nutter, caramel cheesecake, strawberry, or key lime pie. Good day or bad day, Abbott’s Frozen Custard makes everything better!

Hours & Location

📍16406 New Independence Parkway Winter Garden, 34787, US

Visit website

Best Dessert Spots

Don’t be stressed, eat dessert! Be sure to follow and tag us @StuffToDoInOrlando with all your Winter Garden dessert adventures!

Curated by

Nathalia Candelario | Visit Profile >

It’s better in the app

Share

Winter Garden Dessert Guide

VIPs Only 💁‍♀️‍♀️

Best Dessert Spots

Curated by

Nathalia Candelario | Visit Profile >