5 Pizzerias with the Best Pizza in Jacksonville | UNATION

Cancel

Where to grab the perfect pizza in Jacksonville

If you're on the hunt for the best pizza in Jacksonville, you've officially come to the right place and your taste buds are about to have the time of their lives. Whether you're a die-hard thin-crust devotee, a deep-dish dreamer, or just someone who believes more cheese is always the answer, this guide is dishing out all the saucy details on where to find the pies that have earned their spot at the top of Jacksonville's food game.

Our top pizzerias in the 904

Whether you’re after thin crust, deep dish, or loaded toppings, these spots deliver every time.

Pie 95

Enjoy the delicious taste of authentic wood-fired pizza in Jacksonville’s historic Riverside! At Pie-95, they serve up fresh signature pies that will make your mouth water just by reading the menu! They offer a variety of different menu items, ranging from Cheese Please to The Herbivore and The Carnivore. They also have items other than pizza, such as their tasty fire-roasted meatballs which are smothered in Pomodoro sauce and parmesan cheese. Be sure to check out their Burrata Caprese and Arugula Caesar Salad as well!

Tony D's

If you’re looking for authentic New York style pizza, Tony D’s is the spot for you! They offer all your favorite classics, like Margherita, Veggie Lover, and White Pizza, but also have a wide variety of creative pies, too! We’re talking Philly Steak, Buffalo Chicken, and Taco pizzas! For authentic pizzas you’d have to taste to believe – visit Tony D’s!

V Pizza

Enjoy authentic wood-fired pizza at V’s! This delicious eatery serves up “pizza so Italian, it needs a translator!” Bite into heaven with crispy edges and gooey mozzarella cheese. With zero artificial ingredients, you’re only getting pure authentic flavor! Pro-Tip: because it’s cooked in a wood-fired oven, V’s pizza is best if you eat in in-store. If you’d like to bring it home, heat their delicious pies on a pizza stone to keep that amazing crisp!

Serafina's Pizzeria

At this mouthwatering pizzeria, each pie is handcrafted and made from scratch. Meaning – all your favorite classics are created with care, making some of the best pizza in Jacksonville! Try tons of delicious slices with fresh and premium toppings. Plus, enjoy other tasty entrees and appetizers as well! From salads to chicken parm, pastas to heroes, Serafina’s has it all. Pro-tip: be sure to check their daily specials for great deals on delicious meals!

SLICE Oakleaf

Craving pizza on the go Grab a slice from Slice! This Oakleaf pizzeria offers delicious New York- and New Jersey-style pies with all your favorite toppings, and creative ones too. From classics like meat lovers and veggie to innovative pickle and ranch and buffalo chicken pizzas, there’s something yummy for everyone at Slice!

Rodrigo's Craft Pizza

Indulge in delicious craft pizza with Rodrigo’s! This new restaurant is a family-owned pizzeria promising only the best ingredients and carefully crafted dishes. With incredible specialty pizzas, oven baked panuozzos and calzones, and fresh salads, add this Riverside pizza spot to your must-try list ASAP!

Donatos

Donato’s is the best! The pizza comes out quick while still tasting great & their pizza is the perfect addition to a late-night dinner or Sunday Night Football party! They have amazing vegetarian options and also options for meat lovers. Vegetarians can get their cheese pizza with toppings like peppers, onions and mushrooms, as well as their vegan meat offerings! And for everyone else, we suggest the Double Bacon Pepperoni Pizza! And yes, that’s a thing! Be sure to check out their Instagram for weekly giveaways and amazing deals!

Biggie's Pizza

Big on New York Style pizza Head on over to Biggie’s Pizza! This pizzeria serves giant pizza slices that’ll fill you up and satisfy your pizza cravings! Biggie’s Pizza offers a long list of gourmet pies nodding back at their New York inspiration with names like the Godfather, Brooklyn Deluxe, and the Gambino Pie! They serve some of the best pizza in Jacksonville, featuring unique pizza sauces, an assortment of cheese options, and fresh toppings. You can enjoy their pizza creations in an 18” pie or a gigantic 24” slice that’s sold for only $5!

Photo credit Carmines Pie House

Carmines Pie House

Party it up pizza style at Carmines Pie House! From Monday trivia to Thursday craft beer night, Carmines hosts various specials and events alongside their version of the best pizza in Jacksonville! They offer both thin-crust New York-style pizza and Chicago stuffed. To enhance your slice of pizza, add delicious garnishes from their selection of meat, veggies, and gourmet toppings! Plus, they provide vegan-friendly options like vegan cheese and tofu!

MOD Pizza

MOD Pizza is proof that the best ingredient in any recipe is people. When founders Scott and Ally Svenson dreamed up MOD back in 2008, they flipped the script — put your employees first, and everything else falls into place. Their MOD Squad slings fully customizable, made-to-order pizzas and salads with 40+ toppings at a price that never changes (yes, really!). But MOD is so much more than a great slice — they're on a mission to create opportunity and belonging for everyone, championing causes like mental health awareness, childhood hunger, and LGBTQ+ inclusivity. It's not just pizza, it's a whole movement.

FAQs about the best pizza in Jacksonville

Looking for a specific vibe or need to hit dietary goals? we've totally got you covered!

FAQs

Where can I find the best New York-style pizza in Jacksonville? +-
For authentic NY-style pizza, check out Tony D's, Biggie's Pizza, Renna's, or SLICE Oakleaf. Biggie's even serves a massive 24" slice for just $5!
What Jacksonville pizza places are best for families? +-
Serafina's, Mama's Pizza, and Siena's Pizza are great family-friendly picks, offering casual atmospheres, diverse menus, and something for even the pickiest eaters at the table.
Which Jacksonville pizzerias are best for late-night cravings? +-
Donatos is a go-to for late-night pizza, known for quick service without sacrificing quality. Perfect for post-game nights or late Sunday dinners!
Are there good gluten-free or vegan pizza options in Jacksonville? +-
Absolutely! Moon River Pizza, Carmines Pie House, Mama's Pizza, and Vino's all offer gluten-free and/or vegan-friendly options so nobody misses out.
What makes Jacksonville's pizza scene unique compared to other Florida cities? +-
Jacksonville offers incredible variety, from Emangeo's New Haven-style brick-oven pies and Electric Dough's Roman-style pizza inside a historic theater, to Angela's beloved slice window on Beach Blvd. There's truly something for everyone.
How do I find the best pizza near me in Jacksonville? +-
Jacksonville's pizza spots are spread across neighborhoods like Riverside, San Marco, Oakleaf, and St. Johns. This guide covers the top picks citywide to help you find the perfect pie close to home!

Angela's Pizza

Okay, we have to talk about Angela's. This girl grew up in her dad's pizza shop learning the craft since she was 10 years old, and honestly? It shows. At just 18, she's already got people lining up around the block at her little slice window on Beach Blvd across from Beach Bowl. The pizza is thin, crispy, barely any flop, with the perfect snap in the crust and a sauce that just works. This spot is already one of the best pies in Jax — go find out for yourself, and yes, get there early!

Photo credit Moon River Pizza

Moon River Pizza

dough! Moon River Pizza serves pies made the traditional way! They use a hearty tomato sauce spiced with Italian seasoning and freshly grated mozzarella to create some of the best pizza in Jacksonville! For toppings, they offer goodies ranging from artichokes to vegan sausage. Moon River Pizza serves pizzas fit for vegetarians, vegans, meat-lovers, and those who eat gluten-free!

Mama's Pizza

Mama knows best, and at Mama’s Pizza, they know what it takes to make the best pizza in Jacksonville! Each of their pizza pies consists of fresh ingredients and overflow with Mama’s love! Mama’s menu includes a large collection of pizzas to explore including, a Philly cheesesteak pie, BBQ chicken, BLT, and the Mediterranean, among many more. They offer pizzas in both New York style and Chicago deep-dish style! Plus, like many of the other Jacksonville pizzerias, Mama’s provides gluten-free and vegetarian pizzas!

Renna's Pizza

For a slice of freshness and authenticity, try pizza from Renna’s! This Jax pizzeria serves Sicilian and New York-style pizza topped with traditional garnishes like black olives, garlic, banana peppers, pepperoni, and anchovies! Whether you want a simple slice of cheese pizza or an extra-large Sicilian-style pie, Renna’s Pizza has got you covered! Their specialty pizzas serve a variety of flavors, ranging from pepper spicy to garden fresh. They even offer a classic white pizza that mixes rich ricotta with stringy mozzarella for a classy cheesy treat!

Electric Dough

If you're a fan of Prati Italia or Town Hall, Chef Tom Gray has done it again with his newest Jacksonville gem — Electric Dough Pizza! Tucked inside the iconic San Marco Theatre, this place has already become a go-to spot for crispy, authentic Roman-style pizza that keeps people coming back for more. The seasonal salads are fresh and on point, and don't even get us started on the sorbets — the perfect sweet ending to a killer meal. Chef Gray has a serious knack for turning incredible spaces into incredible dining experiences, and Electric Dough is no exception. If you haven't made it out there yet, what are you waiting for?

Emangeo’s

Emangeo’s is serving up some seriously good New Haven vibes with a Jacksonville twist—and they’re not taking any shortcuts! This family-powered pizzeria started from humble food truck roots and has absolutely risen to the occasion, now bringing their brick-oven magic to neighborhoods across town with perfectly charred, hand-stretched pies made the traditional way. They’re all about that slow fermented dough life and creating gathering spots where real pizza craftsmanship meets genuine community love, whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or planning your next catered blowout.

Siena's Pizza

Looking for your new go-to spot in St. Johns? Say hello to Siena's Pizza — the cozy little pizzeria that everyone in the area can't stop raving about! Made with love, quality ingredients, and traditional recipes, every bite hits like a warm hug. From classic favorites to their signature pies, freshly baked and bursting with flavor, this place has a serious way of keeping you coming back for more. And if that wasn't enough, they've also got a full bar with draft beer and fine wine to round out the perfect night. Family-friendly vibes, incredible food, and a space you'll never want to leave — Siena's is the real deal!

Photo credit Caffe Andiamo

Caffe Andiamo

Caffe Andiamo is a gorgeous establishment. It’s clean, modern, and has some great Italian food. Starting with the pizza, the Andiamo is a go-to here. The Andiamo has ricotta and mozzarella cheese with garlic, olive oil, and herbs. We would get the Bruschetta Alla Romana. This pizza is made from Foccacia bread that is brushed with just the right amount of olive oil and herbs. It’s topped with baby greens, prosciutto di Parama, and a diced tomato vinaigrette! Doesn’t that sound amazing?

Rosalia's Italian Restaurant

Grab a slice of New York pizza without having to catch a flight up North at Rosalia’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria! Rosalia’s serves authentic Italian cuisine alongside New York-style pizza! Their list of 14” specialty pizzas offers meat-heavy, veggie-loaded, and mozzarella-melted pizza options. If you love a tasty NY-style pizza, then Rosalia’s might just have the best pizza in Jacksonville Florida for you!

Photo credit Vino's Pizza & Grill

Vino’s Pizza & Grill

Head on over to Vino’s Pizza & Grill for hot slices of pizza covered in fresh ingredients, sporting some classic all-time favorite flavors! From a basic veggie pie to spicy buffalo chicken pizza, Vino’s offers pizza fit for everyone! They even serve gluten-free pizza!

Photo credit Roja's Pizza

Roja's Pizza

Meat-lovers, cheese-lovers, and everyone in between, Roja’s Pizza can fulfill your pizza dreams! Their menu includes a range of pizzas, including a meat-lovers pizza, a vegetarian pizza, and buffalo chicken pizza, among many more. Alongside their collection of pizzas, Roja’s also offers light bites like bruschetta, pinwheels, and mozzarella sticks, and other tasty treats like calzones, Long Island rolls, strombolis, and wings. We love a pizza and wing combo! Don't miss this awesome spot for Pizza in Jacksonville!

Photo credit Casa Dora Italian Cafe

Casa Dora Italian Cuisine

Casa Dora provides a welcoming and cozy environment, serving various Italian staples. This pizza spot makes for an ideal location for large parties with multiple cravings. They’ve got pasta, salads, seafood, and protein-packed dishes! Like many of our listed pizza places in Jacksonville, Fl their pizza selection offers both classics and unique pies! Plus, you can feel right at home by ordering Casa Dora’s customizable slices and bringing your dream pizza bite to life!

Follow us

Follow us on our social accounts to find the best events.

Curated by

Becca McCandless

Duval Native | Sunshine State ☀️ | Aspiring Plant Mom 🌱