Select City

It’s better in the app

Download. Join. Explore.

Download. Sign in. Explore.

Get the app
Get the app

5 Pizzerias with the Best Pizza in Jacksonville

  • March 01, 2023
  • | 10:52 AM

VIPs Only 💁‍♀️

Just kidding! (sorta)

Curate your favorite guides, events, deals, and more with our new Collections feature, available exclusively on the UNATION mobile app.

Grab a slice of some of the best pizza in Jacksonville by checking out our list of pizzerias! Not only did we list our own personal favorites, but we also turned to our Facebook group and asked them for recommendations as well! The result? A perfect list of the absolute best pizza in Jax!  Discover tasty pizza pies, unique topping selections, and more!

5 Pizzerias with the Best Pizza in Jacksonville
📷 Photo Credit: @biggiespizzajaxbeach - Facebook

Biggie's Pizza

Big on New York Style pizza? Head on over to Biggie’s Pizza! This pizzeria serves giant pizza slices that’ll fill you up and satisfy your pizza cravings! Biggie’s Pizza offers a long list of gourmet pies nodding back at their New York inspiration with names like the Godfather, Brooklyn Deluxe, and the Gambino Pie!

They serve some of the best pizza in Jacksonville, featuring unique pizza sauces, an assortment of cheese options, and fresh toppings. You can enjoy their pizza creations in an 18” pie or a gigantic 24” slice that’s sold for only $5!

Hours & Location

Mon & Tues: 4pm – 12am, Wed & Thurs: 11am – 12am, Fri & Sat: 11am – 2am, Sun: 12pm – 12am

Menu
5 Pizzerias with the Best Pizza in Jacksonville
📷 Photo Credit: @CarminePieHouse - Facebook

Carmines Pie House

Party it up pizza style at Carmines Pie House! From Monday trivia to Thursday craft beer night, Carmines hosts various specials and events alongside their version of the best pizza in Jacksonville! They offer both thin-crust New York-style pizza and Chicago stuffed.

To enhance your slice of pizza, add delicious garnishes from their selection of meat, veggies, and gourmet toppings! Plus, they provide vegan-friendly options like vegan cheese and tofu!

Hours & Location

Sun – Thurs: 11am – 9pm, Fri & Sat: 11am – 10pm

📍 2677 Forbes St, Jacksonville, FL 32204

Menu
5 Pizzerias with the Best Pizza in Jacksonville
📷 Photo Credit: @moonriverpizza - Facebook

Moon River Pizza

Taste out of this world pizza made with fresh dough! Moon River Pizza serves pies made the traditional way! They use a hearty tomato sauce spiced with Italian seasoning and freshly grated mozzarella to create some of the best pizza in Jacksonville!

For toppings, they offer goodies ranging from artichokes to vegan sausage. Moon River Pizza serves pizzas fit for vegetarians, vegans, meat-lovers, and those who eat gluten-free!

Hours & Location

Mon – Sat: 11am – 10pm, Sun: Closed

📍 | Murray Hill | Fernandina |

Menu
5 Pizzerias with the Best Pizza in Jacksonville
📷 Photo Credit: UNATION

Mama's Pizza

Mama knows best, and at Mama’s Pizza, they know what it takes to make the best pizza in Jacksonville! Each of their pizza pies consists of fresh ingredients and overflow with Mama’s love! Mama’s menu includes a large collection of pizzas to explore including, a Philly cheesesteak pie, BBQ chicken, BLT, and the Mediterranean, among many more.

They offer pizzas in both New York style and Chicago deep-dish style! Plus, like many of the other Jacksonville pizzerias, Mama’s provides gluten-free and vegetarian pizzas!

Hours & Location

Mon – Thurs: 11am – 11pm,  Fri & Sat: 11am – 12am, Sun: 11am – 10pm

📍9550 Baymeadows Rd, Jacksonville, FL 32256

Menu

Pie-95

Enjoy the delicious taste of authentic wood-fired pizza in Jacksonville’s historic Riverside! At Pie-95, they serve up fresh signature pies that will make your mouth water just by reading the menu! They offer a variety of different menu items, ranging from Cheese Please to The Herbivore and The Carnivore.

They also have items other than pizza, such as their tasty fire-roasted meatballs which are smothered in Pomodoro sauce and parmesan cheese. Be sure to check out their Burrata Caprese and Arugula Caesar Salad as well!

Hours & Location

Tuesday – Saturday :  5pm – 9pm

📍|Riverside | 1510 King St, Jacksonville, FL 32204

5 Pizzerias with the Best Pizza in Jacksonville
📷 Photo Credit: @Rennas-Pizza - Facebook

Renna's Pizza

For a slice of freshness and authenticity, try pizza from Renna’s! This Jax pizzeria serves Sicilian and New York-style pizza topped with traditional garnishes like black olives, garlic, banana peppers, pepperoni, and anchovies! Whether you want a simple slice of cheese pizza or an extra-large Sicilian-style pie, Renna’s Pizza has got you covered!

Their specialty pizzas serve a variety of flavors, ranging from pepper spicy to garden fresh. They even offer a classic white pizza that mixes rich ricotta with stringy mozzarella for a classy cheesy treat!

Hours & Location

Mon – Thurs: 10:30am – 9pm, Fri & Sat: 10:30am – 10pm,  Sun: 12pm – 9pm

📍| South Beach Parkway | Baymeadows |  Argyle village Square | Riverplace Shopping Center | Neptune Beach | 

Menu

Best Pizza in Jacksonville & More!

Pizza, pizza, and more pizza! These hot spots serving the best pizza in Jacksonville offer both unique and classic pizza flavors that’ll put a smile on any pizza lover!

For more great places to eat and explore in Jacksonville, make sure to check out our Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook! Plus, you can download our app to stay in the know of all things happening in Jax and more!

Get Featured on UNATION

Looking for ways to promote an event or feature your business? Fill out the form to learn how to get featured on City Guides and other UNATION platforms.

Choose a package that works for you, and our team will get to work to maximize exposure to your event or business.
Connect with Our Team

Curated by

Serafina Besecker

Serafina Besecker

Serafina is a blogger and author for UNATION's Stuff to Do City Guides. For more insight on the best events and things to do near you, downl...

Contributing curators

Serafina Besecker
  • Alexandra Halbert

Contributing curators

  • Alexandra Halbert
    Alexandra Halbert

Share

Share

Share