Orlando
Share
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest

Where to Find the Best NY Style Pizza in Orlando

A Story By

If thin crust, hand-tossed pizza makes your mouth water then you’re in luck. There’s no shortage of delicious pizza spots serving up some of the best NY style pizza in Orlando. Whether you’re wanting just a slice or the whole box, these Orlando pizza joints are sure to satisfy all of your New York pizza cravings. 

Gitto’s Pizza is catering to both thick crust and thin crust pizza lovers—the best of both worlds. While their New York style pizza won’t disappoint, we recommend trying out one of their stuffed pizzas if you’re feeling a little adventurous. You get double the crust and double the fillings. 

Monday | 10:00am–2:00am
Tuesday | 10:00am–2:00am
Wednesday | 10:00am–3:00am
Thursday | 10:00am–3:00am
Friday | 10:00am–3:00am
Saturday | 10:00am–3:00am
Sunday | 10:00am–3:00am

📍 120 S Orange Ave, Orlando, FL 32801

Tomasino’s is the one place you can come for pizza and leave as family. They’re known for serving big portions like momma and in the locals go-to spot for cheesy, authentic New York style pizza.

If you’re the ultimate pizza lover, try taking on their Made Man challenge by eating a 12 inch stuffed pizza in one sitting. If you attempt it, don’t forget to tag us in all the photos on Instagram @StuffToDoInOrlando. We don’t want to miss it. 

Monday | 11:00am–9:00pm
Tuesday | 11:00am–9:00pm
Wednesday | 11:00am–9:00pm
Thursday | 11:00am–9:00pm
Friday |  11:00am–10:00pm
Saturday | 11:00am–10:00pm
Sunday | 12:00am–9:00pm

📍 2612 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32803

A pizza or a calzone—why pick one when you could have both? At Grato Italian Kitchen in Winter Park they’re serving up the Mezzaluna which is half calzone and half thin-crust pizza. This open, lively restaurant is taking New York style pizza to the next level. 

Monday | Closed
Tuesday | Closed
Wednesday | 11:30am–10:00pm
Thursday | 11:30am–10:00pm
Friday | 11:30am–10:00pm
Saturday | 11:30am–10:00pm
Sunday | 11:30am–9:00pm

📍 528 S Park Ave, Winter Park, FL 32789

Hand-tossed crust, brick oven baked, and over thirty topping offerings—Broadway Ristorante & Pizzeria is the ultimate New York style pizza spot in Orlando. This cozy restaurant prioritizes good old fashioned food and their customers. They even cook up heart-shaped pizzas per customers requests, making in the best spot to celebrate a special anniversary or date night.

Monday | 11:00am–2:00am
Tuesday | 11:00am–2:00am
Wednesday | 11:00am–2:00am
Thursday | 11:00am–2:00am
Friday | 11:00am–2:00am
Saturday | 11:00am–2:00am
Sunday | 11:00am–2:00am

📍 1700 Woolco Way, Orlando, FL 32822

Where’s the one place serving up authentic New York style pizza that’s 30% bigger than competitors pizza’s? It’s NYPD Pizza. The best part, their Metro West NYPD Pizza location offers a 45% off discount to all on-duty police officers. 

Monday | Closed
Tuesday | 11:30am–8:00pm
Wednesday | 11:30am–8:00pm
Thursday | 11:30am–8:00pm
Friday | 11:30am–9:00pm
Saturday | 12:00am–9:00pm
Sunday | 12:00pm–9:00pm

📍 2589 S. Hiawassee Rd
Orlando, FL 32835

“As seen on Food Network” is enough for us to add Tornatore’s Pizzeria to our list of must-try spots in Orlando, Florida. Their new menu, revamped by Chef Irvine on Restaurant Impossible, is now serving up made-from-scratch pizza’s. Nothing but fresh ingredients for this authentic New York style pizza. 

Monday | Closed
Tuesday | 11:00am–9:00pm
Wednesday | 11:00am–9:00pm
Thursday | 11:00am–9:00pm
Friday | 11:00am–10:00pm
Saturday | 4:00pm–10:00pm
Sunday | 4:00pm–8:00pm

📍 3818 Edgewater Dr, Orlando, FL 32804

Fratelli Italian Restaurant is a family owned and operated restaurant, serving up authentic New York style pizza in a cozy, family-oriented atmosphere. Whether you’re dining for lunch or dinner, you’re guaranteed to be welcomed with open arms and leave with a full tummy. 

Monday | 10:00am–9:00pm
Tuesday | 10:00am–9:00pm
Wednesday | 10:00am–9:00pm
Thursday | 10:00am–9:00pm
Friday | 10:00am–9:00pm
Saturday | 11:00am–10:00pm
Sunday | Closed

📍 373 N Orange Ave, Orlando, FL 32801

The Best NY Style Pizza in Orlando

After tasting the best New York style pizza Orlando has to offer, we want to know which spots you liked best. Follow us on Instagram @StuffToDoInOrlando and tag us in your favorite New York style pizza restaurants. 

Kailey Boyer

Kailey Boyer

Kailey Boyer is an Arizona native, currently living her best life in Orlando, Florida. She’s passionate about hunting down and sharing all things her beautiful city has to offer. Making the hidden Florida gems accessible to everyone! You can find her exploring Orlando with a camera in hand, typing away in a local coffee shop, or in a packed car heading to the beach.

Subscribe Now

Get the best things to do in Orlando delivered right to your phone! 
Please enter a valid email address.
Thank you for subscribing!
Weekend Guides
Checkout all the past Tampa Bay weekly Guides in the Stuff To Do Archive
Find Stuff To Do
Discover the best featured and staff pick events in Tampa Bay on UNATION
Connect on Facebook
Join our Stuff to Do in Tampa Bay Facebook group to find more upcoming events

Get the App!

Download the UNATION app and discover tons of local events

Share

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on linkedin

Share

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on linkedin

Share

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on linkedin