Are you wondering, “Where can I find the best pizza places near me?” Look no further! We are the pizza experts in the Tampa Bay area and we’ve done our research so that you don’t have to go searching.
Check our our master guide below on the best pizza places in Ybor City!
New York New York Pizza
Not looking to sit down and want pizza on the fly? Eat where the locals eat! Ybor City locals love to dig in on the thin crust of New York New York Pizza. Whether you’re ordering in from home or want a snack on a late night out, this is always a great spot for a quick slice. Get pizza, pasta, and even subs to fill up!
Due Amici
Come for the pizza, stay for the house made dough! Each day Due Amici hand makes their dough and tops it with the freshest ingredients. Using San Marzano tomatoes from Italy and Sicilian sea salt, you’ll truly get an Italian pizza experience! Next time you’re craving the perfect pie, chill out in their warm space that will feel just like home.
Tampa Bay Brewing Co
For a craft brewery environment and some delicious pizza, look no further than Tampa Bay Brewing Co. This brick walled brewery serves up the best freshly baked pies and house made craft brews! We recommend sitting in their outdoor seating on a cool day, it’s such a nice vibe!
Order up one of their pizzas or a delicious calzone! Our favorite pizza is the Brewer’s Choice, filled to the brim with delicious toppings – TBBC red sauce, pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, onions, poblano peppers, and stringy mozzarella cheese!
Bernini of Ybor
For a more upscale experience, one of our favorite date spots has to be Bernini of Ybor. Their wood fired pizza are perfect for a yummy lunch or a romantic dinner. Pair a pie with a selection from their extensive wine list or a craft cocktail! We recommend checking out their Wild Mushroom pizza, with crimini mushrooms, goat cheese, and other stringy cheeses!
Gaspar's Grotto
If you’re looking for a fun night out, you need to add Gaspar’s Grotto to your list! This is a pirate themed restaurant and patio – with live entertainment, affordable drinks, and delicious pizza! They have plenty of Latin-inspired snacks and entrees, but we definitely recommend their pizza. Check out their wood fired Margherita pizza, made with fresh buffalo mozzarella slices! Want to give it a Tampa spin? Add Cuban style pork as a topping!
Zydeco Brew Works
New Orleans cuisine is one of our favorites! Get all your Louisiana favorites, plus some flavorful flatbreads. We love that they combine Cajun flavors with their pizzas! Check out their creative Creole Flatbread – with Cajun crawfish, spicy andouille sausage, and a creamy alfredo sauce! You’ll love to dine with a bunch of friends in their industrial space, perfect for catching up before a night out.
GameTime Tampa
Old school arcades are a thing of the past! An emporium of state of the art games, GameTime Tampa is a great place to bring the family for a weekend activity. It’s all indoors so it’s great for when it’s raining! Not only do they have games, but they serve great pub style food. Get a pizza to share with everyone! It’s the perfect snack to regain some energy before you get back out on the gaming floor.
Mangia Bene Pizzeria
After a long night out, you’ll want to get some grub before heading home. Open after the bars close is Mangia Bene Pizzeria! This small shop is the place to pick up a slice of thick and thin pizzas. They even have wings, salads, and subs to go along with your meal! Their line will tell you how good their pizzas are! With the perfect balance of sauce, cheese, toppings, and the right price, Mangia Bene definitely has people coming back for more.
Mama Rosa's Pizza
Fro a simple weeknight meal, stop in to Mama Rosa’s Pizza. This neighborhood pizza shop is super solid, with pizzas that are baked to have that perfectly browned crust. They’re even open until 3AM so you can stop in when you get a midnight craving for pizza! We recommend checking out their Buffalo Chicken Pizza, it’s full of flavor – you won’t even need to add any extra cheese or chili flakes on top!