Best Pizza in Tampa Bay: 5+ Must-Try Pizza Spots

Where to find mouth-watering pizza in Tampa Bay

Whether you're craving a classic New York-style slice, a wood-fired Neapolitan pie, or something a little more unexpected, Tampa Bay's pizza scene has you covered. From cozy neighborhood spots to local favorites worth the drive, here are some of our top picks for the best pizza around town!

slider-image-0

slider-image-1

slider-image-2

Madison Avenue Pizza

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Tampa Bay, you NEED this place in your life. Home to the biggest pizza in Tampa Bay at a whopping 32 inches! Slices here are larger than your head, and you have the creative freedom to load up your massive pie with whatever toppings your heart desires.

Photo credit DeGiovanni's Pizzeria

DeGiovanni's Pizzeria

This gem in Carrollwood offers authentic Brazilian and American pizzas made with fresh, house-made ingredients and the kind of warm, welcoming vibe only a family-run spot can deliver! We recommend the garlic knots and a large pie.

Photo credit Eddie & Sam’s New York Pizza

Eddie & Sam’s New York Pizza

Eddie & Sam’s is the pizza place you go to if you’re craving New York thin-crust pizza by the pie or slice. Their triangle slices are big, greasy, and foldable – just like we like ’em. The gelato is amazing, so be sure to save some room for it post-pizza!

Photo credit Santoro's Pizzeria

Santoro's Pizzeria

From a plain slice and Philly cheesesteak to chicken bacon ranch – there surely is a slice you’ll love. Their pizza has a crispy, thin, delicious crust with the tastiest sauce and high-quality toppings!

Forbici Modern Italian

Forbici brings Naples to Florida with authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas. From the simplicity of a classic Margherita to the bold flavors of their specialty pizzas, every bite is a journey through the streets of Italy.

Fabrica Pizza

No matter what side of the Howard Frankland Bridge you’re on, you are in luck! With locations in St. Pete and Tampa, Fabrica offers award-winning Neapolitan pizza that ranks among the best in the world! If you want a pizza like no other, try the Polpette e Pesto; it’s incredible! For dessert, get their Zeppole with Nutella!

Jay Luigi

A cozy spot beloved by locals for authentic Italian pizza and hearty pasta dishes. The crust is perfectly baked, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. Great for a casual dinner or sharing a pizza with family and friends!

Photo credit New York New York Pizza

New York New York Pizza

If you lose your friend at the bar, chances are they’re probably at New York New York Pizza. With multiple locations over Tampa Bay, you’ll never miss an opportunity to get a classic New York thin-crust pizza.

The Violet Stone Pizza & Sandwiches

The destination for artisanal pizzas and mouthwatering sandwiches! From the classic Margherita to the inventive Fig & Prosciutto, every pizza is cooked to perfection in their brick oven, ensuring a crispy crust and bubbling cheese with every bite.

3 Corners Pizza

When you’re at Water Street Tampa, this is the spot to hit for a classic New York-style slice. Our go-to is the Veggie Pizza, but you really can’t go wrong with anything on the menu! Don’t skip the dry rub wings—they’re perfectly seasoned and always a hit.

Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar

This Ybor City favorite serves up classic NY-style slices, pasta, and all your Italian comfort food cravings. The late-night vibe makes it perfect for a fun night out with friends. Don’t miss their specialty pies—they’re big, cheesy, and always satisfying.

Photo credit Water + Flour

Water + Flour

If you’re craving pizza with a little extra flair, this is your go-to spot. We love their brick-oven sourdough pies—they’re crispy, chewy, and loaded with fresh, flavorful toppings. Our favorite? The Margherita with a twist, but you have to try one of their creative seasonal pies too!

Pane Rustica

A South Tampa favorite. This casual neighborhood cafe makes amazing pizzas, salads, and craft cocktails – a great spot to meet up for a lavish but low-key dinner! Located in an unassuming strip mall, you can either choose to eat in their dining room and watch the pizzas come out or sit at the bar. We love their hand-tossed-style pizzas, like yummy Spinach Pizza or Bacon Gorgonzola – delicious! Vegan options are available too.

Photo credit Bella's Italian Cafe

Bella's Italian Cafe

Looking for a more rustic-style pizza? This is one of our favorite spots for great classic Italian dishes, perfect for dates too! Their dough is made with beer from an original Venetian recipe – definitely a must-try! Check out their Meatball Pizza, made with their house-made meatballs and sweet peppers.

Photo credit Gourmet Pizza Company Tampa

Gourmet Pizza Company

If you love a specialty pie and tons of unique pizza options, order in to Gourmet Pizza Company. This locally owned pizza company is commonly visited by South Howard locals for an easy weeknight meal, especially if you want low-carb, vegan, and gluten-free options! You can choose from cauliflower crust, vegan cheese, and gluten-free crust.

Photo credit Westshore Pizza

Westshore Pizza

Visit the original Westshore Pizza to see where this popular Tampa Bay chain got started. pizza place serves up New York-style pizza, delicious Philly cheesesteaks, and buffalo wings. Definitely save this spot in your phone for your next cheat day or when you need to order in for a pizza party!

Photo credit Sally O'Neal's Pizza

Sally O'Neal's

Dine al fresco at Sally O’Neal’s, a South Howard classic! Their signature pies are a hit with the locals, with a new, unique pie available each month, like a Cuban or Chicken Asiago Cheese Pizza! They even have delicious baked pastas and entrees, sure to fill any Italian food craving.

Photo credit Bernini Restaurant

Bernini of Ybor

For a more upscale experience, one of our favorite date spots has to be Bernini of Ybor. Their wood-fired pizzas and ornate atmosphere are perfect for a yummy, upscale lunch or a romantic dinner. Pair a pie with a selection from their extensive wine list or a craft cocktail!

More pizza spots you can’t miss in Tampa Bay

Grab a friend, share a pizza, and taste what Tampa Bay’s pizza scene is really all about!

Bella Roma NY Pizza

Bella Roma NY Pizza

Legendary late-night NY-style pizza with thick crust and big flavor.

Papi's Pizza

Papi's Pizza

Puerto Rican-inspired pizza with bold flavors and tropical twists.

Hot Rocks Pizza

Hot Rocks Pizza

Neighborhood favorite with consistently great pizza and tasty toppings.

Sogna Napoli Trattoria & Pizzeria

Sogna Napoli Trattoria & Pizzeria

Authentic Neapolitan pizza that tastes just like Italy.

Reziero's NY Pizza

Reziero's NY Pizza

Classic NY-style pies that locals love for flavor and foldable slices.

Street Crust

Street Crust

Creative, handcrafted pies with unique toppings in a fun Tampa setting.

Hidden gems and local favorites

From giant pies to cozy neighborhood pizzerias, these spots are serving up some serious flavor.

Tampa Pizza Company

Tampa Pizza Company

Paul’s Chicago Pizza

Paul’s Chicago Pizza

Cristino's Coal Oven Pizza

Cristino's Coal Oven Pizza

Verrazzanos Pizza Sunset Point

Verrazzanos Pizza Sunset Point

Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza

Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza

Flippers Pizzeria

Flippers Pizzeria

Cappy’s Pizza

Cappy’s Pizza

Three Brothers Pizza

Three Brothers Pizza

Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria

Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria

Ava

Ava

Stay in the know

Have the best things to do in Tampa Bay sent straight to your inbox

By submitting this form, you consent to receive informational (e.g., order updates) and/or marketing texts (e.g., cart reminders) from UNATION, including texts sent by autodialer. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency varies. Unsubscribe at any time by replying STOP or clicking the unsubscribe link (where available). Privacy Policy & Terms.

Follow us

Follow us on our social accounts to find the best events.

Curated by

D. P. Camejo Sanchez

Content Writer ☕️