Best Places for Pizza in South Tampa & Satisfy your Cravings

Are you looking for the best pizza in South Tampa? No worries! Whether you’re looking for deep dish or New York style, there’s plenty of options for you to choose from. Check out our master guide below on our favorite spots for pizza in South Tampa, then let us know which you are visiting first!

New York New York

? New York New York Pizzeria

If you don’t want all the glitz and glam, you don’t have to sacrifice food quality! Get the best pizza in a fast food style experience at New York. This pizzeria perfected the classic New York style pie – with extras like rich pastas and sandwiches.

We love this spot for a late night bite! Would you believe that this spot is open later than most bars in South Howard? Feed your late night cravings, whether it’s after a night out or when you get a ravenous pizza craving at home.

?533 S Howard Ave, Tampa, FL 33606

WEBSITE

Sally O'Neal's

? Sally O’ Neal’s

Dine al fresco at Sally O’Neal’s, a South Howard classic! Their signature pies are a hit with the locals, with a new unique pie available each month – like a Cuban or Chicken Asiago Cheese Pizza! They even have delicious baked pastas and entrees, sure to fill any Italian food craving.

Dine on their refreshing outdoor patio or get delivery! Sally O’Neal’s is one of the rare spots that delivers gluten free pizza, just as delicious as the real stuff too!

?1319 S Howard Ave, Tampa, FL 33606

WEBSITE

Tampa Pizza Company

? Tampa Pizza Company

Healthy pizza options can taste great! Don’t feel guilty about eating their delicious pies – nutritious options for any dietary plan! Whether you are vegan, gluten free, vegetarian, soy free, dairy free, or just want a nutritious tasting pizza, this is the spot for you. Their flatbread style pizzas are super yummy – check out their Steak Chimichurri pizza, it’s the perfect dinner pie to share with friends.

Don’t skip out on dessert! If you’re a chocolate lover, you need to try their heavenly Nutella Dessert Pizza.

?777 N Ashley Dr C, Tampa, FL 33602

WEBSITE

Westshore Pizza

? Westshore Pizza

Surely you’ve heard of Westshore Pizza before, but have you been to the original? Visit the original Westshore Pizza to see where this popular Tampa Bay chain got started. pizza place serves up New York style pizza, delicious Philly Cheesesteaks and buffalo wings. Definitely save this spot in your phone for your next cheat day or when you need to order in for a pizza party!

?4802 W Bay Ct Ave, Tampa, FL 33611

WEBSITE

Forbici

? Forbici

For a modern twist on Italian pizza, Forbici is definitely a crowd favorite. Join Forbici on their beautiful outdoor patio, with a candlelit view of Hyde Park Village shops and cafes. If you’re used to traditional pizza, don’t knock the traditional! The square pizza at Forbici is addicting – you will be craving the gooey cheese and buttery crust! Our favorite pizza has to be their signature Cup & Char pizza with pepperoni, pomodoro, mozzarella, and fresh parsley.

?1633 W Snow Ave, Tampa, FL 33606

WEBSITE

Gourmet Pizza Company

? Gourmet Pizza Company

If you love a specialty pie and tons of unique pizza options, order in to Gourmet Pizza Company. This locally owned pizza company is commonly visited by South Howard locals for an easy weeknight meal – especially if you want low carb, vegan, and gluten-free options! You can choose from cauliflower crust, vegan cheese, and gluten free crust.

As for toppings, they have the classics but also shrimp, crawfish, hummus, vegan style meats, and even escargot! Create the most unique pie you can dream of and take a break from the regular large cheese pizza.

?610 S Armenia Ave, Tampa, FL 33609

WEBSITE

Bella's Italian Cafe

? Bella’s Italian Cafe

Looking for a more rustic style pizza? Bella’s Italian Cafe is one of our favorite spots for great classic Italian dishes – perfect for dates too! It’s casual but still pretty so it is a bit special.

Enjoy their pastas but don’t skip out on their delicious pizzas! Their dough is made with beer from an original Venetian recipe – definitely a must try! Check out their Meatball Pizza made with their house made meatballs and sweet peppers.

? 1413 S Howard Ave #100, Tampa, FL 33606

WEBSITE

Pane Rustica

? Pané Rustica Bakery & Cafe

Pane Rustica is a South Tampa favorite. This casual neighborhood cafe makes amazing pizzas, salads, and craft cocktails – great spot to meet up for a lavish but low key dinner! Located in an unassuming strip mall, you can either choose to eat in their dining room and watch the pizzas come out or sit at the bar. We love their hand tossed style pizzas, like yummy Spinach Pizza or Bacon Gorgonzola – delicious! Vegan options are available too.

?3225 S MacDill Ave, Tampa, FL 33629

WEBSITE

Cappy's Pizzeria

? Cappy’s Pizzeria

Calling all Chicago deep dish lovers! (No worries, they have a great hand tossed style pizza too.) Cappy’s has some of the best deep dish pan pizzas in town. Their chunky red marinara sauce, gooey cheese, and crispy crust will have you coming back for more. But with these huge portions, one slice might be enough!

? 3200 W Bay to Bay Blvd, Tampa, FL 33629

WEBSITE

Ava

? Ava

Ava is a well loved spot for pizza in South Tampa, known for their rustic but modernly chic space. We love visiting Ava for their fun brunch and dollar saving happy hour! If you’re looking for a deal Ava has great happy hour that not only includes some of the best craft cocktails in Tampa but also pizzas!

We recommend sitting on their trendy covered patio and ordering the La Bestia pizza. It has delicious sausage, tomatoes, arugula, and dollops of ricotta cheese!

?718 S Howard Ave, Tampa, FL 33606

WEBSITE